# How to choose the right agency as an influencer

Choose an agency that shares your values, whose people earn your trust from the first meeting and that knows the sectors you work in today and the ones you want to grow into. Before signing, check the team’s professionalism, talk to creators who already work with them and look at how long their talent stay and how much they have grown.

By [Amalia Mariotti](https://amagency.eu/en/about-us/amalia-mariotti/), Founder & CEO · Updated: 10 November 2026 · https://amagency.eu/en/guides/how-to-choose-the-right-agency-as-an-influencer/

## Shared values

The first thing to find out is whether you and the agency care about the same things. The agency brings you brands and says yes or no to the offers that arrive in your name: if it judges them differently from you, you will find yourself weighing partnerships your community would not understand.

At Amagency the first meeting with a creator is for exactly this. We talk about what you share, who follows you and the brands you would never work with, and only then about contracts. If our values do not match, we say so straight away, because that suits both sides.

- Ask which partnerships they have turned down, and why.
- Share your limits (categories, brands, topics) and watch how they react.
- Look at the roster: do you see yourself in it, or would you be the odd one out?

## Meet who will look after you

You sign the contract with people. The talent manager is the person you will hear from most: they negotiate for you, back you up when a deadline slips and tell you no when an offer does not suit you. They need to earn your trust, and you only find out by meeting them, ideally in person.

- Who will be your day-to-day contact, and who covers when they are away?
- How many talent does each manager look after?

## Today’s sectors and tomorrow’s

Check which sectors the agency works with now: fashion, beauty, food, travel, sport, family. If yours is among them, it will already have the right contacts. But also ask where it is heading: the sectors it is investing in tell you whether you can grow with it or will outgrow it in two years.

- Which brands in your sector has it worked with recently?
- If one day you change topic or format, can it follow you?

## Check their professionalism

Professionalism shows in the details: a written contract, the agency’s percentage stated before you sign, set payment times, clear briefs, and compliance with the rules on influencer advertising. Ask to see a sample contract and a brief from a past campaign: an organised agency has them ready.

- Exclusivity, length, renewal and notice: are they written down and clear?
- Who negotiates fees, and how do they keep you informed?
- How does it handle disclosure of sponsored content (#adv)?
- At the end of a campaign, do they tell you which data from your profile to share with the brand, and how?

## Ask creators like you

Contact two or three creators on the roster with numbers and content similar to yours, and if you can, someone who has left. Ask how they find it, whether they are paid on time and whether they are listened to when they turn an offer down. An agency that works well will give you the contacts without fuss.

## How long talent stay and grow

A roster that changes every year is a warning sign. Ask how long the talent have worked with the agency and what has changed for them: a larger, more engaged community, partnerships that renew, bigger brands. Ask for two or three concrete stories, with the creators’ names and the brands they worked with.

## Red flags

If you notice any of these, stop and ask questions before signing.

- They ask you to pay to join or to be “trained”.
- They rush you, or the contract is only verbal.
- They cannot tell you who will look after you or which brands they work with.
- They promise follower numbers or guaranteed earnings.

## Frequently asked questions

### Is a big agency or a small one better?

It depends on how much attention you will get. A big agency may have more brands, a smaller one can follow you closely. What matters more is who will look after you every day and how well they know your sector.

### Do I have to pay to join an agency?

No. A serious talent management agency earns when you work, through a percentage of the partnerships it brings in, stated in writing before you sign. Be wary of anyone asking for an entry fee.

### How can I tell whether our values are really aligned?

From the questions they ask you. An agency that cares about values asks what you talk about, who you speak to and what you would never do, before it even mentions brands and fees.

## Sources

1. [AGCOM, FAQ su Linee guida e Codice di condotta per gli influencer (2026)](https://www.agcom.it/sites/default/files/media/allegato/2026/Allegato_B_operativo_influencer.pdf)

## Further reading

- [How influencer agencies and talent managers work](https://amagency.eu/en/guides/how-influencer-agencies-work/): What an influencer agency does for creators, what a talent manager handles, how to join a roster and what to check in a management contract.
- [AGCOM influencer rules in Italy: brand and creator duties](https://amagency.eu/en/guides/agcom-influencer-rules-italy/): AGCOM influencer rules in Italy: how to disclose ads, gifts and events, who counts as a relevant influencer, the AGCOM list and what brands must do.
